I've had issues with my server not showing up in the community tab with my old host, but usually re-installing Oxide (followed by several restarts) fixes it. I'm not having that problem with the new host I'm trying, however I am having a slightly different issue. My server shows up for me no problem, but it's much slower to appear in the list. After hitting refresh, my old server shows up immediately. My new one takes roughly 10 seconds to show up. Probably even longer for others. They're located in the same place (Dallas) and the ping is slightly lower on the new host.

Also, for a bunch of my players, it literally just won't show up at all. The host said I shouldn't be having any issues, but I'm still getting a ton of messages about it. I'm able to instruct them to connect manually, but this would obviously be a problem for new players going forward because they just won't know the server even exists. Like I said, it shows up for me just fine, so I'm having a hard time diagnosing it and I can't think of why this would be an issue.

The only influence Oxide has over your server listing is of it shows under Modded or Community by setting either setting the "modded" tag or not. The actual server listing i handled by Steam and the Rust client; which would depend on your server not being blacklisted with Facepunch, Steam being able to see your server, and no filters being applied on the Rust client that would prevent it from showing.

That's what I figured, but it just doesn't make any sense to me why half my players can see it and half can't. I made sure they're in the right tab and entering the correct search term, but after refreshing it just never shows up. It's in their history but it's not in the normal list. Old one shows up, new one doesnt...

Edit: Seems like most of the players having an issue are from Europe. Server location and ping are identical to the old one though, so it shouldn't make a difference I would think.