Player not in default group?Solved

How is this even possible? The rest of the players are showing up in their assigned groups with no errors, but this guy...

[Better Chat] Were [name & Steam ID removed] does not seem to be in any BetterChat group - falling back to plugin's default group! This should never happen! Please make sure you have a group called 'default'.

Player are always in the default group unless you removed them from it. Oxide itself handles group assignment each time a player connect to your server.
In response to Wulf ():
Player are always in the default group unless you removed them from it. Oxide itself handles group a...

That's exactly what happened. I removed the default group because it was adding "player" titles along with other titles. Like a moron I missed the priority setting being false. 

All good now though ;-)

Locked automatically